Blog

The combinations most players never find

In Props you can drag one item onto another. Usually nothing happens. But most rounds have one pair that fits together, and when you find it the two items turn into a third and your score for the day is multiplied by 1.2.

Across the 24 rounds that have had a combination, an average of 13% of players made it.

(This names characters and items from past rounds.)

The ones people found

The best by a long way was Snake Plissken on 22 October. The combination was a tape and a tape player, and 49% of players made it.

After that:

  • John Keating: a Beethoven record and a record player, 27%.
  • Paddington Bear: slices of bread and a jar of marmalade, 27%.
  • Gollum: a demo and a tape player, 26%.
  • Fletcher from Whiplash (2014): a jazz recording and a CD player, 25%.
  • The Dude: vodka, coffee liqueur, cream and a tumbler. 21% started

mixing and 14% finished the White Russian.

  • Peter Venkman: a nuclear power cell and a proton pack with no power,

20%.

You can see what those have in common. A tape goes in a tape player, a record goes on a record player, and bread and marmalade make a sandwich. You don't need to have seen the film. You just need to have owned a tape player.

Paddington had a second step, by the way. Put the marmalade sandwich under the hat and you get a sandwich-filled hat. 1% of players got that far.

The ones people didn't

At the other end:

  • Lee Abbott from A Quiet Place (2018): batteries and a toy space

shuttle, 1%.

  • Edward Scissorhands: the scissor hands and an ice block, 2%.
  • Doctor Strange: a half-eaten apple and the Eye of Agamotto, 3%.
  • Eddie Brock: a chocolate bar and tater tots, 3%.
  • Chuck Noland from Cast Away (2000): a branch and an ice skate, 3%.
  • Will Hunting: a lighter and a mathematical proof, 4%.
  • Ellen Ripley: a pulse rifle and an incinerator unit, 4%.

Some of those you'd only try if you remembered the scene. Edward Scissorhands carving the ice is in the film. The apple and the Eye of Agamotto is a few seconds of Doctor Strange (2016). A chocolate bar and tater tots is what Venom eats.

But batteries in a toy is as obvious as a tape in a tape player, and hardly anyone made that one. So it's not only about knowing the film.

What actually decides it

It's whether you can see both halves.

You don't get the whole inventory at the start. Some of it is behind the Rummage cards, and a rummage costs a guess. On five rounds both parts of the combination were in front of you from the first second. On those, an average of 26% of players made it.

On the other nineteen, at least one part was behind a rummage, and the average was 10%.

That explains the batteries. The batteries and the toy shuttle were both behind rummages, at different depths, so a lot of players never had the two of them on the table together. And 30% of players never play a Rummage card at all.

It also explains the one that looks wrong the other way. Severus Snape's combination, powdered asphodel and a wormwood infusion, had both parts showing at the start and only 10% made it. But 88% of players named him, and 35% did it on the first guess. My guess is that for most people the round was over before they thought to try mixing a potion.

If you want the points

Before you guess, look at what's on the table and ask whether any two things belong together: something and the thing it goes in, two ingredients, a weapon and its missing part. Try it. The first wrong combination of the day is free, and after that it's 50 points a time, against a fifth of your whole score if it works.

And if you rummage, look again. A new item might be the other half of something you've been staring at.