Blog

Everybody guesses the co-star

On 12 October the first actor in Typecast was Kurt Russell. Nearly half of all players, 49%, guessed Tom Hanks.

That looks mad until you see the board. One of the films on it was Forrest Gump (1994). Kurt Russell is in Forrest Gump: he's the voice of Elvis, uncredited. Players looked at a row of blanks from 1994 with a huge rating, worked out which film it was, and named the man on the poster. The next most common wrong guesses were Robin Wright and Gary Sinise.

They'd done the hard part right. They'd just picked the wrong person from the cast.

It's the same every time

I went through every actor Typecast has used, 144 of them, and pulled out the wrong guesses that at least one player in ten made. The biggest ones all look like the Kurt Russell day.

  • Don Cheadle: 48% said Robert Downey Jr. The board had Iron Man 2

(2010) and three Avengers films on it.

  • Tom Felton: 44% said Daniel Radcliffe, 36% said Rupert Grint and 35%

said Emma Watson.

  • Charlie Day: 39% said Chris Pratt. They're both voices in *The Lego

Movie* (2014).

  • Ben Kingsley: 37% said Liam Neeson, for Schindler's List (1993).
  • Hugo Weaving: 35% said Elijah Wood, for The Lord of the Rings.
  • Clancy Brown: 33% said Morgan Freeman, for The Shawshank Redemption

(1994).

  • Christopher Plummer: 33% said Ed Asner. Both of them are voices in

Up (2009), and Asner is the lead.

  • Edward Norton: 33% said Brad Pitt, for Fight Club (1999).

In every one of those, the player has recognised a film from its year, its genre, its rating and the number of letters in its title. That's difficult and they did it. Then they've gone for whoever's name comes to mind first when you think of that film, and it's never the person further down the cast list, which is who the board belongs to.

And then there's Brad Pitt

Brad Pitt was a common wrong guess on 20 of the 144 actors. Nobody else is close. Leonardo DiCaprio is second on 9, then Ryan Gosling on 8 and Tom Hanks on 7.

Usually there's a reason. He's in Fight Club with Edward Norton, and in Inglourious Basterds (2009) and 12 Years a Slave (2013) with Michael Fassbender, and 30% of players guessed him for Fassbender. He's been in so many films with a big cast that he's a fair guess for almost anyone: on 15 of those 20 actors, he really had made a film with them.

On the other five he hadn't. John Goodman, Mark Ruffalo, Daniel Craig, Jeffrey Wright and Josh Hutcherson have never been in a film with Brad Pitt, and at least one player in ten guessed him for each of them anyway. He's what people type when they need to type somebody.

Why it's not a bad guess

A wrong guess in Typecast still tells you something. If the actor you named is in a film on the board, their name appears under that row. So when you guess Tom Hanks and "Tom Hanks" shows up under the 1994 film, you now know for certain that it's Forrest Gump, and the question has changed from "who is this" to "who else is in Forrest Gump".

That's worth a guess. What isn't worth a guess is doing it twice. On the Tom Felton day plenty of people went through more than one of Radcliffe, Grint and Watson (the three percentages add up to more than 100), and all three of those tell you the same thing.

Guess the star once to confirm the film. Then stop thinking about the poster and start thinking about who's standing at the back.